Showing posts with label Jack Ryan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Jack Ryan. Show all posts

Friday, March 2, 2012

He's Winning, He's Winning, He's Winning

George Washington knocked Jack Ryan down like a cherry tree.
Washington's trek to the Rushmore Four has been smooth sailing; way easier than crossing the Delaware.

Washington vs. Ryan
George Washington     19 (67.9%)
Jack Ryan 9  (32.1%)

However, hhis marks the first time that Washington received less than 90% of the vote. It could be a sign of things to come for Washington. It will be an uphill battle for him.

This week's numbers were eerily similar to last week's result, which had Jackson over Whitmore 20-9. However, unlike last week, all was quiet on the commentariat front this time around. That means we're forced to sift through our Tweets.
We share this because it leads to a discussion question: If Ryan loses points because he was once portrayed by Ben Affleck, would being portrayed by Chris Pine help or hurt him? We ask because this is supposedly happening.

Adding to the list of other characters like Han Solo, Indiana Jones and Jack Donaghy, would having Captain Kirk on his side in the Arena help Ryan?
Or, at least, it was announced over two years ago. After all of this time, there still seems to be no sign of this actually happening, so we guess it doesn't really matter.

Washington will meet Andrew Jackson in the first Rushmore Four match, March 19. The winner of that will obviously advance to the Championship. The loser will get another chance at a victory and try for 3rd place. Next week, Barack Obama will meet Josiah "Jed" Bartlet.

Monday, February 27, 2012

Washington vs. Ryan



George Washington
1st President of the United States
Served: 1789-1797
Ages during term: 57-65

Arena Experience
1st Round: 92.5% of 40 votes against Mike Brady
2nd Round: 93.75% of 16 votes against Grover Cleveland
3rd Round: 95% of 21 votes against Martin Van Buren

PROS: Is one helluva guy. You know, the kind who can wrestle/box you into submission, or also outmaneuver the vastly superior forces of his opponent into submission. Either one.

CONS: Doesn't have a spotless record, militaristically-speaking.

Jack Ryan
Served as President in the Tom Clancy novels Debt of Honor, Executive Orders, and The Bear and the Dragon.
Age: Indeterminate. Wikipedia gives an birthdate in 1950, and Debt of Honor is implied to take place sometime around 1995-96. So, yeah, something like that.

Arena Experience
1st Round: 76.47% of 34 votes against Millard Fillmore
2nd Round: 75% of 20 votes against Tom Beck
3rd Round: 53.33% of 45 votes against Harry S Truman

PROS: Let's review how he became president. After a lifetime of being plain old awesome, "they" decided to make Ryan the vice president -- very similar to how Theodore Roosevelt got the gig. The night he was "veeped" (that's a word, right?), a jet crashed into the Capitol, killing lots of people including the president, but excluding Ryan.

CONS: He's a daredevil who has a habit of biting off more than he can chew, and we're not just saying that because he was once portrayed by Ben Affleck who once portrayed Daredevil. True, he has had a long history of prevailing, but his luck is bound to run out eventually.

Pre-Fight Analysis
Tony: If this were a battle of name recognition, then hey, it'd probably be no contest. My informal polling tells me that 117% of people have heard of George Washington. Jack Ryan? Eh, slightly less than that. However! This is a fight to the death, a no-holds-barred contest of physical prowess and mental fortitude. In that light, this contest becomes a little harder to call.

Both of these guys have impressive credentials: Ryan as a world-saving CIA analyst, Washington as the Father of the United States. Again, those don't seem equal, but I encourage our voters to look a little deeper at this one. To explore the Arena space, if you will. If they do, I think they'll be impressed at how close this match should be.

And then, they'll vote for Washington, because: seriously.

Doug: This is a fight between two people who got shit done. It may not have looked pretty at times, but in the end, the fat King George stopped pushing us around / the world wasn't obliterated.

That being said, I think the only thing that may ruin things for Ryan would be the fact that things weren't constantly exploding around him. The lack of explosions could probably just distract him. It's going to take him a while to get used to the fact that there's only one person after him at a time, and that he has no other risks to watch out for. Once he gets a handle on that, he could probably take Washington down.

One more thing before I go. Imagine how awesome the painting Ryan Crossing the Delaware would be.

Oh, yes. Oh... oh... yes.
This seems kind of boring in comparison, doesn't it?
The Chief: Vote! Comment! Only one of these men will make it to the Rushmore Four.

Washington vs. Ryan


Friday, January 20, 2012

Truman Defeats Ryan

FOR THE RECORD: A headline in Friday's post incorrectly identified Harry S Truman as the victor in this week's fight. The headline should have named Jack Ryan as the winner.
We regret the error. It must be something about Truman that inspires wildly inaccurate headlines. To our defense, there was a lot more at stake when the Chicago Tribune made a similar error on the cover of its November 3, 1948 issue.
Truman vs. Ryan
Harry S Truman        21 (46.7%)
Jack Ryan   24 (53.3%)

We knew going in that this was going to be a close one. Truman led for most of the week, but Ryan turned things around and surged ahead in the last day of voting. This was one of our closest matches so far made more interesting by the fact that it marked the first time since the 1st Round where both fighters got more than 20 votes.

Though Ryan barely got more votes, Truman clearly dominated with the commentariat.
We'd like to thank DEisenhower34 for yet another insightful account of the history the textbook people are afraid to tell us. We had no idea that this was the reason behind that policy, nor were we aware of the basis of Samuel Jackson's persona. So educational!

We'd also like to pause for a moment to point out that the HttCttD blog was inaugurated a year ago today. Fifty-two eliminations, 263 comments, and 1,409 votes later and the real excitement hasn't even begun yet. Thanks to everyone for adding to our fun.

Ryan will go on and face George Washington in the Washington Bracket Finals, scheduled for Feb. 27.
Join us next week when David Palmer from 24 takes on Barack Obama.

Monday, January 16, 2012

Truman vs. Ryan


Harry S Truman
33rd President of the United States
Served: 1945-1953
Age During Term: 60-68

Arena Experience: Ran up against James K. Polk in round one, and came away with 70% of the vote. Round 2 saw him going up against Calvin Coolidge, and he did even better, gaining 76.9%.

Pros: Truman's ill-tempered, quick thinking, and tough as nails. And, at the risk of sounding simplistic and repetitive, there was also the whole Atomic bomb thing, so... yeah.

Cons: Owes a bit too much to powerful political friends. Also has a history of making decisions without thinking too hard about them; could be bad news.

Jack Ryan
Served as President in the Tom Clancy novels Debt of Honor, Executive Orders, and The Bear and the Dragon
Age: Indeterminate. Wikipedia gives an birthdate in 1950, and Debt of Honor is implied to take place sometime around 1995-96. So, mid forties?

Arena Experience: Ryan has been a pretty consistent fighter, getting about three-fourths of the vote each time. He sent the 13th president, Millard Fillmore, out of the Arena on a match that ended on a Friday the 13th with 76.5% in the 1st Round. In the 2nd Round, he met up with Tom Beck from Deep Impact and got a solid 75%.

Pros: I don't know where to start. He's Jack Ryan. He was a CIA intelligence analyst who later became a field agent. From there, he was able to pull off some ridiculous shit, putting his life in danger all in the name of preventing World War III. Seriously, check out some of the stuff he's done. That list takes you up to the part when he survived being in the Capitol when a 747 crashed into it. So on top of putting himself out there, the guy has remarkable survivability.

Cons: He's a daredevil and has a habit of getting in over his head. While he always manages to find his way out of trouble, he does have a habit of depending on luck to get him out of the bigger jams. That's good an all, but luck has a tendency to run out at inopportune times.

Pre-game Analysis
Doug: It's would be fair to say that his his laundry list of amazing badassery reads like something out of a spy thriller novel turned action movie. If I wanted to split hairs and be more accurate, I'd say it reads like a series of spy thriller novels turned action movies, because that's exactly what's going on here. Jack Ryan's such a badass that they got the guy who plays Han Solo and Indiana Jones to play him in half of the movies. Add that with the fact that he's about two decades younger than Truman, and the conclusion I come up with is that Ryan should win this.

Yeah, Truman wasn't one to be messed with during World War I. But that was 30 years before he took office. Sure, maybe there's muscle memory for that sort of thing that would awaken when Truman enters the Arena. But Ryan's still in the same shape. Don't forget that Ryan's first act as president -- even before he took the presidential oath -- was surviving the burning wreckage caused by a plane crashing into the Capitol. Fighting and surviving are all Ryan knows at this point.

Tony: I'm not gonna lie to you-- I have no idea who's going to win this one. Neither of these two has been challenged thus far in their Arena adventures, meaning that they're both strong fighters in terms of this little bit of ridiculousness we've got set up, here. Now, we've got the HttCttD version of the Unstoppable Force vs. the Immovable Object.

Does Ryan have the edge here? You could say that, I guess. But on the other hand, Truman didn't take shit from anyone, and had the whole "buck stops here" thing going on. Also, Truman dropped the effing bomb, whereas Ryan always was always running around trying to stop those things from going off. I think this is gonna be close, but I think Truman has the edge.

Truman vs. Ryan

Friday, October 28, 2011

Avoiding Clear and Present Danger

Jack Ryan showed Deep Impact's Tom Beck who is un perdador.
That's such a shame, because they appear to be getting along okay in this photo.

Beck vs. Ryan
Tom Beck  5  (25%)
Jack Ryan      15 (75%)

Tom Beck may be a good person to have around in times of global disaster, but when it comes to hand-to-hand combat, Jack Ryan's the guy you may want to put your money on (not that we condone gambling).

On the subject of a mini-debate raised on Monday's post, while we're wholly unqualified to forecast the outcomes of two nonpresidents fighting, we believe a fight between singer-songwriter Beck and Jake Ryan of 16 Candles would also most likely lead to a Ryan victory.

Jack Ryan moves on and will face Harry S Truman in the Round of 16 in a fight scheduled Jan. 16.
Join us next week when Franklin D. Roosevelt faces David Palmer from the TV series 24.

Monday, October 24, 2011

Beck vs. Ryan


Tom Beck
Played by Morgan Freeman in the film Deep Impact
Age: Freeman was 60 when the movie was filmed

Arena Experience: Beck had Richard Nixon (the real one, not just his head) to kick around in the First Round, and finished with 56.5% of the vote. Maybe that doesn't sound impressive, but you'd have to imagine that Nixon found some way to cheat.

PROS: Beck never loses his cool. Comet heading for Earth? Yeah, that sucks, but "life will go on." Comet washed away everything East of the Appalachians? "Life will go on." A quick tip for anyone looking to defeat Beck in the Arena: don't try to play the mental game with him, because it's not going to work.

CONS: Beck is kind of a bigmouth. He spilled the beans about the planet's impending doom to a reporter. Thankfully, the reporter was nice enough to sit on the biggest story in the history of reporting. Otherwise, he'd have to find a way to calm a nationwide panic (Not everyone is a collected as Beck). Maybe he could keep quiet on his fighting strategy, but who knows?

Jack Ryan
Served as President in the Tom Clancy novels Debt of Honor, Executive Orders, and The Bear and the Dragon
Age: Indeterminate. Wikipedia gives an birthdate in 1950, and Debt of Honor is implied to take place sometime around 1995-96. So, yeah, something like that.

Arena Experience: The 2-seed in the original Washington bracket, Ryan faced Millard Fillmore in the first round, and came away with 76.5% of the vote.

PROS: Had a rather spectacular pre-presidential resumé as a CIA intelligence analyst turned occasional field agent. Seriously, go back to Ryan's first fight and read the list of shit he pulled off. He's smart, capable, resilient, and most importantly, he survives a lot of things that would easily kill lesser men.

CONS: On the other hand, Ryan is a bit of a daredevil who should never have been put in the field to begin with. As such, he gets by on luck a lot of the time, and that's maybe not the best thing to rely on. He also has a tendency to get in over his head — arguably, that's how he became president to begin with.

The Fight
Tony: Look, we all know Beck is a pretty cool guy. I mean, even being a born and raised Scientologist. Odelay and Guero are great albums, and even his more recent stuff, like The Information or Modern Guilt have some good songs on them. And he put some great work into the Scott Pilgrim soundtrack. So, really, I don't want it to seem like I'm dumping on this guy unnecessarily. But, he just doesn't have the combat experience to stand a change against someone like Jack Ryan.
 
Doug: Well, what does Jake Ryan really have going for him? I mean, yeah, he's super dreamy. Speak to any heterosexual woman who was under 25 when Sixteen Candles came out, and they will most likely say that they would do him, no questions asked. I think it's such a foregone conclusion that their boyfriends/husbands wouldn't even consider it cheating — some may even be jealous that they didn't get to watch. The guy has it all. But is he a fighter? No.
He was barely able to take care of the walking, talking Asian stereotype in an off-screen scuffle.
He let his girlfriend walk all over him. She made him throw these raging parties at his house whenever his parents were out of town. His house was wrecked every time, yet he never stood up to himself. When the crazy chick got drunk and slept with the freshman geek, only then did he feel like he could get away scot-free.

How is someone like that going to handle a fight against Beck, who — wait...

Tony: Wait, what happened here? Weren't we squaring multi-platinum selling recording artist Beck against Tom Clancy protagonist Jack Ryan? I mean, it seemed like an odd matchup, but whatever, man, I'll put Ryan against anyone.

Doug: See, and I thought we were talking about Jake Ryan. I'd imagine his charisma would win him a presidential election, years after he and Samantha Baker break up. I don't know, I figured maybe there was a Sixteen Candles sequel that was made years later that no one saw.

Tony: I implore you not to give Hollywood ideas.

Doug: Actually no, that could work. It could come in 2016. Not only would the year end in 16, but it would also be 32 (or 16 times 2) years after the original. Samantha could have a kid of her own who is turning 16. Ooh, I have a better idea. She has a son who is trying to cheer up a girl having a shitty 16th birthday, and that could be the daughter of Anthony Michael Hall's character. And Jake is president for some reason.
FACT: President Ryan once gave car keys to a drunken teen who had no driver's license.

Worse movies have been made. If the cast of American Pie could come back to celebrate their 13-year high school reunion (because that's what it would be, people), then my awful piece of crap idea for a Sixteen Candles sequel, sadly, could be greenlit.

Tony: Just... please don't tell me you already have a screenplay for this abomination...

Doug: No, I'm having some difficulties with the script (it sucks), but I don't think I should let that stop me. I mean they remade Footloose, didn't they?

So we're talking about Jack Ryan? Oh, that actually makes more sense.

Isn't Jack Ryan a bit over-prepared for this? I feel like the moment he enters the ring, he's going to be keeping an eye out for terrorists ready to swarm the Arena or for some normal looking spectator who may be a trained assassin. He's going to be so worried about the possibilities outside of the ring that he won't even be paying attention to Tom Beck and his fists: Wolf & Biederman.
You don't want to be around when Biederman connects.
Tony: Over-prepared? I don't think you can be over-prepared for the Arena. But if "over-prepared," you mean, "has infinitely more experience in close combat with people who want to kill him," then yes, he certainly is over-prepared. I mean, seriously, he's killed scores of terrorists personally, he's averted world wars, he's stared down a would-be assassin in the Oval Office itself.

Meanwhile, Tom Beck has... gotten lucky saving Earth, I guess? He certainly hasn't fought anyone, aside from Nixon, and that wasn't exactly an overwhelming victory. Meanwhile, Ryan is younger, healthier, and ass-kickinger. This isn't going to be close.

Doug: I was just making the point that sometimes Ryan's threats come from a surprising source. If he enters the ring and sees Beck, would he actually be concentrating on beating Beck up or would he be worrying about some unforeseen threats? Because Beck has one thing on his mind: getting rid of Ryan. Ryan's mind, on the other hand, may be drifting between Beck and places to hide in case a plane is flown into the Presidential Gladitorial Arena.

You'd have to imagine with all that has been through, Ryan must be psychologically exhausted at this point. He's about ready to crack.

Tony: And looking for Ryan to break is a fool's game. Maybe if he had "broken" after his wife and daughter were attacked by terrorists, you'd have a point, but no, that only hardened his resolve and caused him to accept a CIA post he had previously turned down.

No, in this fight's Beck is going to be... a lost cause.

Doug: Just because we haven't seen Beck fighting terrorists all by himself, it doesn't mean he's unable to. He's got resolve dripping out if his ears. Life will go on for him as Ryan learns that the deep impact from Beck is where it's at.

The Chief: As curious as I am about how a Beck/Jake Ryan would go, we are bound by our duty to not put that up for consideration.

Be sure your voice is heard in this week's fight between Tom Beck and Jack Ryan. Voting closes Friday, 9am MDT.

Beck vs. Ryan

Friday, May 13, 2011

Hell Comes to Blogtown

Jack Ryan became The Sum of All Fears for Millard Fillmore.
"Here's my card, in case you want another beating."
This shouldn’t really be a surprise as Ryan was in the No. 2-seed spot.

Ryan vs. Fillmore
Jack Ryan26 (76.5%)
Millard Fillmore      8 (23.5%)

Not to put Fillmore down, but this really wasn’t an upset in any way. We put Ryan in the No. 2 spot for a reason: he’s Jack Ryan. We didn’t even consider the fact that Ryan may be confused in this world we created, which would make him angrier.
We wouldn't want to detract from this week’s Comment of the Week, but some members of the commentariat may have been unable to share their wisdom and philosophy. Anyone wanting to leave a comment for us anytime after yesterday evening was greeted with this:
Don’t worry, we got the same message. This explains why this post was close to being late or why we were unable to check out the traffic source for that strange, but welcomed, spike in votes we got last night. We’d blame some Friday the 13th curse, but this nonsense started yesterday, and no one ever talks about Thursday the 12th — though they probably should.

Jack Ryan advances to the 2nd Round and is scheduled to face Deep Impact’s Tom Beck Oct. 24, which should be interesting, because it isn’t the first time a Morgan Freeman character has crossed paths with Ryan.
"Psst! It's on, pretty boy."

Join us next week, when Blogger will hopefully allow us to bring you the first match of the Marshall Bracket: Air Force One’s James Marshall vs. Franklin D. Roosevelt.

Wednesday, May 11, 2011

The Hazards of the Ryanverse

The world of Tom Clancy's Jack Ryan novels is an... interesting place. Compared to the "real" universe? Well, there are some pros and cons. In the Ryanverse, the rest of the world's nations seem incredibly wont to trying to stick it in America's grill. Culprits include America's real-life enemies (Iran!), frenemies (China!), and even America's ostensible friends (India! Japan!). Then there are the rogue actors, such as the Arab terrorists who nuke Denver, or the eco-terrorists who want to use a form of weaponized Ebola to wipe out 99% of humanity (this happened in one of the Rainbow Six novels, which are decidedly less Ryan-centric, but are still set in the same world).
On the other hand, terrorists in the Ryanverse are probably 250% hotter than they are in real life. So, there's that.
Did any of that strike you as a little... odd? Yes, it's fair to say that once Clancy could no longer rely on the crutch of the Cold War, his search for scum and villainy led him far afield. It's somewhat strange, as the Russians weren't the only enemies that Ryan squared off against while the aforementioned Cold War was still on; the drug lords of Clear and Present Danger and the Irish terrorists of Patriot Games stand as testaments to that. Yet, once the Big Bad USSR was out of the way, Clancy couldn't help but get a bit silly. And nowhere is the proof of this more apparent than in tracking the ups and downs of the office of the President of the United States during the time from The Hunt for Red October on through Dead or Alive. So let's take a look at that timeline, shall we?

First, some notes for comparison: in the last 30 years or so, you'd have to agree that the American Presidency (and Vice Presidency) has been remarkably stable. We've had no Vice Presidents resign or be replaced in that time span, and there has only been one time that the President has come close to not completing his term (the Hinkley assassination attempt, though if you want to include Clinton's impeachment, we'd say that's fair). Also, we should point out that the Ryanverse makes reference to the presidencies of Reagan and George H.W. Bush, so the presidents listed here start serving some time after that. So! The first person we have to contend with is:
  • "The President": The president from The Hunt For Red October through Clear and Present Danger is never actually named in the novels. Movie versions of those two books name him as James Bennett. The start of Bennett's term is never really explained, but he ran for reelection in 1988, which certainly muddies things. Bennett intentionally tanked his campaign after the events of Clear and Present Danger; apparently he wanted to keep the events of that book secret, and had he been reelected, everything would have come out. So he falls on his sword, leading to the election of...
  • J. Robert Fowler: Fowler came to office a widower, which conveniently allowed him to start banging his National Security Adviser, Liz Elliot. Elliot, unfortunately, wasn't the biggest Ryan fan in the world (which is a clue right there how well this whole thing would turn out), leading her to screw Ryan into not receiving and credit for the whole, Mid-East Peace thing. Whoops! Fowler's presidency seriously came unraveled when terrorists nuked the Super Bowl; believing the attack came from the Soviet Union, he brought the two countries to the brink of World War III before Ryan could get on the hotline and calm everyone the hell down. But things weren't over! The terrorists responsible for the Denver attack managed to plant a false trail leading back to the Ryanverse's Iranian dictator. Enraged, Fowler ordered a nuclear strike on the Iranian city of Qom. Fortunately, Ryan was once again able to defuse the situation by invoking two-man rule (the thing in thrillers where two people have to turn their keys in tandem for a nuclear missle to be launched) and then refusing Fowler's orders. Two days after all of this mess, Fowler broke down, realizing he had just come very close to screwing the pooch, and turned things over to his Vice President...
  • Roger Durling: Fortunately for everyone, Durling was both mostly competent and drama-free. So, naturally, Durling was killed when a rogue Japanese pilot plowed his 747 into the U.S. Capitol (for those of you keeping score at home, this happened in the novel Debt of Honor, which was published in 1994). Fortunately, prior to this little... event... Durling had filled the then-vacant Vice President position by nominating...
  • Jack Ryan! Ryan's presidency was turbulent to say the least, with multiple small wars breaking out, a biological attack from the United Islamic Republic (read: Iran), a very major war breaking out between China and Russia... not good times. Also, a UIR sleeper agent attempted to assassinate Ryan, though this attempt was thwarted in part due to the precautions undertaken because of the Ebola threat. Still, freaking Iran, man. Anyway, Ryan served out Durling's term, and was elected for one of his own, and then things get a little squirrley. Depending on what you read, Ryan either served his whole term, or resigned in its midst. So, depending on which narrative you subscribe to, Ryan was either succeeded by...
  • Robert J. Jackson: One of Ryan's best friends throughout the Ryan novels, Jackson became Ryan's Vice President as the Ryan Administration attempted to rebuild the government after it was almost entirely destroyed at the end of Debt of Honor. Jackson either then replaced Ryan, or campaigned to replace him when he did not run for re-election. However: Jackson was an African-American. No big deal, right? Well, in the Ryanverse, it was a little bit of a deal, and Jackson was assassinated by a KKK member while campaigning in Mississippi.
  • (or) Ed Kealty: Oh, Kealty. Where to begin with this guy? Well, to start, Kealty was Durling's original Vice President. However, Kealty had to resign following a sex scandal. Now, you hear "sex scandal," and you think... "affair?" Well, kind of. Actually, while serving in the Senate, Kealty drugged and raped one of his staffers. This didn't come out until he made it to the Vice Presidency, and though his political capital meant he managed to avoid prosecution, he did have to resign. Once Ryan became President, Kealty immediately started a court battle, contending that he (Kealty) had never actually resigned. Kealty then sued Ryan when, during the Ebola outbreak, Ryan's closing off all insterstate travel prevented Kealty from... well, interstate travel. Kealty claimed this violated his constitutional rights. The courts threw the case out, and as a bonus, Kealty had named Ryan as President in said case, so his earlier case became null at the same time. Now that's Jenga. Anyway, Kealty ran for the presidency against Jackson, and was nowhere close in the polls when Jackson was killed. However, the incident came too deep into the election cycle for another candidate to be named, and Kealty thus cruised to office.
The latest Jack Ryan novel implies that Kealty's presidency will be short, as Ryan himself has gotten too pissed off over Kealty's many faults; he is thus planning to pull a Cleveland and get elected to his second nonconsecutive term.
    So, let's review: that's either five or six presidents in a span of twenty years. To put that in perspective, the Ryanverse's 44th President of the United States (Durling) came to power around 1995. In the real world? The 44th president is... the current one. You know, the one who was elected in 2008?

    Of course, it's not like this sort of lunacy never happens in the real world. Consider this: in the twenty-year span from 1840 to 1860, we went through eight presidents. Those circumstances were pretty mundane compared to the Ryanverse; we just went through a long string of one-termers and two who couldn't even make it to one term. However, the twenty years leading to the Civil War really shouldn't be seen as a beacon of stability in American history.

    Bottom line: if you are an American in the Ryanverse, you stand a high chance of being killed in a terrorist attack, and the stability of the presidency is about naught. But you're not going to lose any wars. So, there's that.

    Polls are still open for this week's matchup of Ryan and Fillmore! Head over to Monday's post if you haven't voted; and leave some comments, dammit!

    Monday, May 9, 2011

    Ryan vs. Fillmore

    NOTE: Although three actors have portrayed Jack Ryan, none of which played him while he was actually president, we decided to have Tom Clancy himself represent him on top here. If you would rather imagine Alec Baldwin, Harrison Ford, Ben Affleck or even yourself playing the role of Jack Ryan this week, feel free.
    Jack Ryan
    Served as President in the Tom Clancy novels Debt of Honor, Executive Orders, and The Bear and the Dragon
    Age: Indeterminate. Wikipedia gives an birthdate in 1950, and Debt of Honor is implied to take place sometime around 1995-96. So, yeah, something like that.

    PROS: Have you seen this guy's resume? — Holy crap, what hasn't this guy done. Let's try and tick off the major bullet points from before he becomes president, He...
    • Defended the Prince and Princess of Wales from an Irish terrorist attack, and subsequently defended himself and his family from subsequent attacks
    • Personally helped shepherd a defecting Russian submarine captain, along with his newly-christened and somewhat revolutionary submarine, into American hands
    • Orchestrated a scheme in which he manages to retrieve a high-ranking Soviet official (who also happened to be passing intelligence to the U.S.) AND the chairman of the KGB; during this particular operation, Ryan literally fell out of the plane ferrying the Russians out of Russia and was briefly held by the KGB.
    • Became Active Deputy Director of the CIA's Intelligence wing, whereupon he uncovered and helped to dismantle a highly illegal (and as a bonus, disastrous and ineffective) operation that attempted to destroy Colombia's drug cartels. During this time, Ryan personally traveled to Colombia to help extract U.S. assets (read: soldiers) who had been abandoned when everything started going tits-up.
    • Concocted a highly-complicated (and somewhat successful) Israeli-Arab peace deal involving the Vatican, and Swiss troops.
    • Successfully deterred President Fowler from ordering a nuclear counter-strike following the destruction of Baltimore Denver in a nuclear terrorist strike. Had Folwer succeeded, shit would've really hit the fan (trust us — this part is a little too complicated to explain in a bullet point)
    • Gained access to the Soviet/American "Hot Line" during the above crisis and managed to prevent the U.S. and USSR from starting WWIII.
    • Became National Security Adviser to President Durling, where he enacted a plan to save the American economy following various hijinxs and chicanery by Japanese warmongers.
    • Outfoxed the aforementioned warmongers with a series of covert attacks and other ballsy maneuvers, all of which led to President Durling asking Ryan to become his next Vice President (the previous VP having had to resign due to a sex scandal). Which led to the last bullet point, where Ryan.
    • Narrowly survived an attack where a disillusioned Japanese pilot crashed his 747 into Congress during a joint session (where Ryan was to be formerly introduced to the nation as VP).
    "Did somebody start something? 'Cause I'll finish it."
    That right there? Is a TREMENDOUS amount of badassery. And, of course, we only covered the time before Ryan made it to the White House. AFTER that? Well, he continued to kick ass, of course, but in the interests of keeping things short (really, we do try to do that around here), we're going to stop there.

    Survivability — When we first meet Jack Ryan, he's a mere CIA analyst — a spook, in other words — with no ambitions nor training for field duty. All of a sudden, he has to be flown out to the middle of the Atlantic to help bring in a defecting Russian and his submarine. And he manages to do so with mimimal fuss! Well, by that we mean he manages to do so by shooting a man, and then by hanging out while the sub he is on sinks another Russian sub by ramming it. Welcome to field work, Jack Ryan!
    Helllooooooo, sailor!
    Over the years, Ryan manages to stare down all number of threats, some physical, others international. While chaos ensues around him, Ryan stands tall, figures out the best course of action, and executes said course. Seriously, the man just knows how to roll with the punches. Best example? We'll say it came at the end of the Sino-Russian war (don't ask what that is), when the Chinese kiiiiiiind of accidentally managed to launch an ICBM... at Washington. President Ryan refused to evacuate, instead opting to stay behind on the U.S.S. Gettysburg, which was carrying an experimental missile defense system. Granted, said system had never worked before, but Ryan's presence alone (we assume) willed it to destroy the incoming ICBM, thus saving the capital, and Ryan. Oh, and as an added bonus, when China's student population discovers that not only was their country fighting a bullshit war in Russia, but it also almost managed to, you know, nuke someone, they rise up and overthrow the Chinese government, literally overnight. The lesson? Is that you do NOT fuck with Jack Ryan. Period.

    CONS: Daredevil — More often than not, Ryan ends up charging into various situations without really thinking things through. Like that whole Russian airport scenario we talked about above. Ryan basically risks his life on the premise that, due to his diplomatic immunity, the Russians won't kill him. Now, obviously they don't, but consider that Ryan had just helped two extraordinarily prominent ant-Russian intelligence sources get away from Russia. And consider that once Ryan was dumped on the tarmac, he was in the hands of probably the one Russian who had the most to lose from all that shit going down. Jesus, that's... that's some confidence. If Ryan is that reckless in the ring, he could be in for some trouble if his luck runs out.
    Fortunately for Ryan, his universe doesn't have any of... this.
    Bites off a bit more than he can chew? — One of the big hallmarks of the Ryan Administration is the Ryan Doctrine. What's that? Well, it's Ryan's declaration that anyone ordering an attack on the United States' "territory, possessions, or citizens" will get blowed the fuck up. There are a lot of good intentions in this idea — Ryan, after all, wanted to tell the world that the United States would not be taking any more shit, thankyouverymuch, and also explicitly said that retaliatory strikes would be designed to punish the shit-kickers directly, rather than affecting the innocent civilians and citizens that shit-kicker may have presided over.

    However, it's important to note that the Ryan Doctrine was a terrible idea. Really. First, it overturned President Ford's ban on U.S.-based assassinations of foreign leaders, thus making it open season for any foreign government with a beef against America's president (granted, in the Ryanverse, everyone seems to have wanted the sitting president dead, regardless of anything Ford said, so I guess it's a wash). Second, the doctrine's success is only guaranteed in a universe where a) the United States military can do anything it wants at any time, with little to no consequences, and b) America's intelligence-gathering services never fuck up. Also, the doctrine doesn't consider the aftermath of the United States blithely picking off other world leaders it doesn't like. Can you say "global instability"? We thought so. Though, again, global instability is a real hallmark of the Ryanverse, so given all that, maybe the Ryan Doctrine makes sense. Still, before leaving office, Ryan managed to create another top secret intelligence organization, which he supplied 100 blank pardons to cover any crimes they might commit in the name of keeping America safe.

    Yeah, hard to see that coming back to bite anyone in the ass.

    Millard Fillmore
    13th President of the United States
    Served: 1850-1853
    Ages during term: 50-53

    PROS: Good at being No. 3 — We here in the U.S. have a two-party system. The two parties in question have shifted through the years. Originally, the rivalry was Democratic-Republicans vs. Federalists and now it’s Democrats vs. Republicans. Whigs came and went somewhere along the way (we’ll get to that later).

    Every so often, a third-party candidate comes along and shakes things up. Fillmore was one of these people. In 1856, he ran under the Know-Nothing Party with Andrew Jackson’s nephew as a running mate. They ended up getting 21.6% of the popular vote, which is the one of the best showings of any third-party candidate.

    Even when the system is stacked against him, Fillmore does better than expected. Though it may speak volumes about our hideously ugly history that more than one-fifth of our voters were supporting a party whose sole platform was "Hey, don't you think there are too many Irish and Germans around?"

    His spirit lives on... on TELEVISION — The ‘80s sitcom Head of the Class starred Howard Hesseman as a teacher to a group of gifted students.
    In the beginning, the show took place in New York's fictional Monroe High School. Then, somewhere along the lines, they changed it to Millard Fillmore High School.

    No, they didn’t up and change schools. The writers just changed the name of the school. Why would they change the name of the school from Monroe, who is pretty well-known and has a Doctrine for crying out loud, to Fillmore, who kind of gets lost in the crowd among other antebellum presidents?

    I’m guessing Fillmore visited a show’s writer, either in a dream or in real life... who knows? “Look,” Fillmore said, “I’m not getting any respect. No one knows who I am. Do something about this.” The writer was like, “Whatever, Franklin Pierce, or whoever you are.” Then Fillmore’s ghost must have given him quite a scare because the jock extras at 0:12 in the show’s opening are wearing jackets with F’s on them, not M’s.
    Fillmore's wish is granted
    Fillmore’s spirit is a very powerful being, and today he can be seen playing a very powerful man on the successful television show 30 Rock.
    "Lemon"
    Okay, that may be Alec Baldwin and not Fillmore, but I think the resemblance is pretty uncanny. You many not think Millard Fillmore could do very well in a fight, but ask yourself how well Jack Donaghy could do.

    CONS: Nerd — When he got the White House, Fillmore was a little taken aback by the fact that there were no books to be found — I guess all of the books from the Adams and Jefferson days were in the Library of Congress — so he started the White House library.

    No, that’s good. Presidents should like to read.
    The supposed favorite of a recent president
    I’m not attacking the guy for being an intellectual. If this were a Jeopardy! tournament, this would serve him well. It’s not, though.

    Oh, and he did serve in the New York militia, but his military service was limited. So limited that his Wikipedia article dedicates exactly one sentence to his military career.

    He had also served as New York State Comptroller, but thanks to the show Archer, when I think of the position of comptroller, I think of Grade-A weiner Cyril Figgis.
    Ineffectual weakling or not, the man gets a surprising amount of action.
    Last of the dying breed of people who seem to die easily — Millard Fillmore was our last Whig president, and he wasn’t even elected to that position. He was elected vice president to Zachary Taylor, who died in office after serving 16 months. In fact, the only other Whig elected president was William Henry Harrison, who died a month after inauguration.

    Whig presidents don’t seem like very hardy people. Maybe that’s why Fillmore tried to run under a different party in 1856. He knew that if he was elected as a Whig, his days would be numbered.

    The Fight
    Tony: Okay, look, maybe I'm being a little overconfident here, but I really don't see why Jack Ryan is supposed to be concerned with a patsy like Fillmore. The thing about Ryan is? All his enemies get crushed. Terrorists attacking his family? Bam, dealt with. Iranian agents weaponize Ebola and release it throughout the country? Blown up and/or extradited to the U.S. Rogue Chinese militants try to nuke Washington? The entire government gets replaced. So what's supposed to happen here? Millard Fillmore shows up, he's gonna get dealt with, Jack Ryan style.

    Maybe Fillmore thinks he can somehow befriend Ryan, but history shows that's not a good idea, either. Ryan's friends and mentors have a bad history of getting assassinated, or coming down with cancer, or getting blown up when a 747 plows into the Capitol. Pretty much, the only survivor in Jack Ryan's world is... Jack Ryan. Oh, and I guess his direct family. But I'm sure once Clancy gets desperate, Jack Jr. is gonna feel some pain.
    Doug: I'd have to say, as unrealistic as the premise of our blog is, it couldn't hold a candle to the ridiculousness that is Tom Clancy's "Ryanverse."

    That is to say, to me, reanimating each and every single president and having them meet — sometimes with fictional presidents... some of whom are animated — for a Battle Royale seems marginally more likely than a hijacked plane getting anywhere near the Capitol building during a joint session of Congress. Add to that every single thing that happened to Ryan. It's very unlikely that all of this would happen to one person.
    Grover Cleveland fighting another version of himself?
    Meh, I've read sillier things in Clancy novels.
    Ryan will be miffed to learn that his luck won't be that great in the slightly more realistic universe of the Presidential Gladiatorial Arena™. It will be like in Last Action Hero when Jack Slater (Arnold Schwarzenegger) went to the real world and was surprised to learn that simply shooting at a car a few times won't make it explode.

    Ryan is up for a bit of a rude awakening when he realizes that just showing up won't ensure survival.

    Tony: I can come along with this in theory... but only in theory. Look, Millard Fillmore has about a 0.3 rating on Jack Ryan's threat assessment board. Out of 100.
    Care?
    And that's perhaps being generous. I mean, Jack Ryan has legitimate close-combat experience that Fillmore just doesn't have. What, is Fillmore supposed to draw strength by being vaguely on television? I'm just not seeing it.


    Doug: Okay, I'm pretty sure you just made up the Jack Ryan's threat assessment board, along with the scale and the 0.3 rating Fillmore gets, is something you just made up. I'm curious how other things would fall on this scale. What kind of score do puppies get? What about non-WASPs?


    Granted, given the things Ryan has survived, Fillmore would probably rank low on the list. However, like we've both said, luck plays heavily in Ryan's life. When luck runs out, it does so in crazy, life-ending ways. For example, think of Bobby Leach. Leach was a daredevil and the second person to go over Niagara Falls in a barrel. Oh, he suffered injuries, but he survived. That takes a massive amount of luck, right? Well, luck might have a Newtonian element to it, because Leach died fifteen years later... from an infected leg... which he got from slipping on an orange peel.
    Because fatally slipping on a banana peel would have been considered pedestrian.

    An orange peel may would have probably gotten a 0.3 on Bobby Leach's threat assessment board, which made it all the more easier for the orange peel to kill him. Say what you will about Millard Fillmore, the man's tougher than an orange peel.

    Tony: I'm not here to suss out the entire rating scale. The point is that Fillmore's got nothing that's going to surprise or overwhelm Jack Ryan. Though I imagine puppies probably score an "adorrrrrrrrable!" Because they're puppies.
    Holy shit, I can't stand the adorable.

    The only way Ryan should be worried about your Bobby Leach comparison is if Tom Clancy was into ironic deaths, and he's pretty much not. When he wants you dead, you're going to go in a manner befitting your character and whatever crazy whackadoo plot Clancy's pushing at the time. It's not going to be something like slipping on an orange peel. I don't know what the Ryanverse equivalent of that would be. Getting blown up by your own Predator drone? Sure, let's go with that.

    Fillmore may be tougher than an orange peel, but I doubt he has the... zest to kill like Ryan does.

    He's going down.

    Doug: You make is sound like Tom Clancy is going to decide the outcome of the fight and not our voters. If our voters want an ironic death, they'll vote for an ironic death. Stop disenfranchising our voters, Tony.

    Obviously, given Ryan's past experience, Fillmore is going to pretty much be depending on luck or irony for the win, but that doesn't mean a Fillmore win isn't impossible. If the triskaidekaphobic vote comes out in full force, they might decide that having the 13th President in of the United States enter the ring could be just the thing to spell doom for Ryan. Shit, the dude's run has got to end at some point.

    The Chief: Polls close 9am on Friday the 13th, a bad day for friggatriskaidekaphobes.
    Vote, comment and tell your friends!

    Ryan vs. Fillmore